Second Circuit lets NY and CT enforce gambling laws against Kalshi, Coinbase
The Second Circuit denied Kalshi and Coinbase injunction bids, letting New York and Connecticut enforce gambling laws against sports event contracts.
- DeskSports betting
- Filed
- Updated
- Read2 min
Filed by SpinHerald Newsroom
| Desk | Sports Betting |
|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | US-NY |
| Parties | Kalshi · New York State Gaming Commission · Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) |
| Sourcing | 1 source: trade media |
| Check status | verified (5 Nov 2026) |
On Tuesday, the Second Circuit denied Kalshi and Coinbase’s requests for injunctions that would have prevented New York and Connecticut from enforcing their state gambling laws against sports event contracts while the prediction market operators appeal. “Upon due consideration, it is hereby ordered that the motions are denied because Appellants have failed to make the required showing that an injunction pending appeal is warranted,” the court order states. The decision means both states could enforce bans against their sports event contracts.
Appeals covered
Tuesday’s decision covers three appeals being considered together: Kalshi’s dispute with officials from the New York State Gaming Commission; Kalshi’s challenge against Connecticut’s Department of Consumer Protection and state officials; and Coinbase’s separate challenge against Connecticut Atty. Gen. William Tong and other state officials. The companies say their sports contracts are swaps covered by the Commodity Exchange Act, putting them under federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission regulation. New York and Connecticut disagree. They argued that the contracts are essentially sports bets and should be regulated under state gambling laws. Sports betting attorney Daniel Wallach called the decision “a major win for both states.”
Lower-court rulings and other circuits
U.S. District Judge Analisa Torres ruled against Kalshi in July, rejecting its request for a preliminary injunction. She found that the Commodity Exchange Act did not override the state’s gambling laws as applied to the company’s sports prediction markets. In Connecticut, U.S. District Judge Vernon D. Oliver denied Kalshi’s preliminary injunction request in August, concluding that the company’s sports contracts did not qualify as swaps under the CEA and that federal law did not displace Connecticut’s traditional authority over sports wagering. New York sued Kalshi on July 31, accusing the operator of running an illegal gambling business. A lawsuit to stop Kalshi from offering sports event contracts to residents was filed on Aug. 26 in Connecticut. States like Massachusetts, Michigan and Nevada have already implemented such bans. Elsewhere, the Third Circuit previously sided with Kalshi in its dispute with New Jersey, while the Sixth and Ninth Circuits have ruled in favor of state regulators.
Sources
- Legal Sports Report · Industry media · primary source ·
Spotted a mistake? Report an error — see our corrections policy.
More from the desk
- Prediction markets face scrutiny after Democrats take Congress
- Ohio regulator warns licensees over services to unlicensed prediction markets
- New York Gaming Commission seeks court order to compel Kalshi subpoena compliance
- US government and CFTC ask court to halt Utah's criminal and civil cases against Kalshi