Industry desk

Clase pitch-rigging trial opens as defense and prosecutors clash over bettor

Opening statements began in Emmanuel Clase’s alleged pitch-rigging trial; prosecutors allege 18 rigged pitches while both pitchers maintain their innocence.

  • DeskIndustry
  • Filed
  • Updated
  • Read1 min

Filed by

The Spodek arena in Katowice during an esports event
Photo: Filip Hajdóci / Pexels · Pexels License
Fact sheet
DeskIndustry News
JurisdictionGlobal
Sourcing1 source: trade media
Check statusverified (6 Nov 2026)

Cleveland Guardians pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz face federal charges of conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery. Federal prosecutors accuse Clase of rigging 18 pitches as part of a larger betting conspiracy, and accuse Ortiz of rigging two additional pitches during the 2025 MLB season. Since their arrests last fall, both pitchers maintain their innocence.

Opening statements

Assistant U.S. Attorney Rebecca Urquiola delivered the opening statement for the government. Michael Bronson, an attorney for Clase, said conversations were “not code words,” but “ordinary conversations about rooster fighting.”

Samuel E. Landes, an attorney for Ortiz, described Enoc Pena as a person who allegedly lied on tax returns, loan applications and immigration forms. Pena, according to Landes, has placed more than 7,000 bets amounting to at least $725,000. In total, bettors tied to the scheme won at least $450,000 on the pitches, prosecutors alleged. Landes told the jury the government’s case “sits on Pena,” and “you can’t trust Pena.”

Urquiola indicated that the government intends to call a forensic accountant who will testify that the defendants sought to conceal a series of alleged kickbacks. Urquiola told the jury: “The defendants actions are criminal and that’s why we are here.”

Early witnesses

On Thursday, Milwaukee Brewers catcher Bo Naylor testified out of order as a defense witness. While Naylor told the jury that there was “nothing unusual” about the pitches from his former Guardians teammates, he admitted under cross examination that he did not know that gamblers could bet on individual pitches until the case arose.

Prior to Naylor’s testimony, the government called MLB Senior Vice President Paul Mifsud and DraftKings Director of Special Investigations Joel Trella. DraftKings used geolocation data to determine that 161 bets were placed from Clase’s residence, The Athletic reported. U.S. District Judge Kiyo A. Matsumoto told a jury earlier this week that the trial may last through early-December.

Sources

  1. iGaming Business · Industry media · primary source ·

Spotted a mistake? Report an error — see our corrections policy.

MLBBetting integrityMatch-fixingSportsbooksGlobal

More from the desk

  1. Catcher Bo Naylor tells MLB pitch-rigging trial disputed pitches looked normal
  2. Plannatech CEO says sportsbooks can flag suspicious pitch bets as Clase and Ortiz trial continues
  3. Brazil signs Macolin Convention to strengthen fight against match-fixing
  4. NCAA joins Bad Actor Program to tackle harassment of athletes by sports bettors